Philip Alexander Carlton

A Bullet with Butterfly Wings

I couldn't sleep last night after overhearing some news that broke my heart. Here's a bit of a story, broken up by a collection of old paintings that capture the mood (mostly 10-12 years old, everything but 'Cascade' was painted from direct observation' and all but one are self-portraits). I should also preference this by saying that's it's directed primarily towards artists who aspire to work full time in their field; all people referenced shared this dream.

I saw one of my best plein air friends recently at a week-long event, and as usual his work was brilliant. But he didn't have a full set of four pieces hung. Not because of weather, but because he's been forced to start working retail full time. This was after 12 years of knowing him as a masterful and locally revered full time oil painter, someone who's ability and career I had only ever dreamed of matching some day. 


"Darkened" - 8x10" - 2008 - Oil on canvas

I shared a gallery show with him and another artist friend just over a year ago. Exhibiting side by side with them had been a great honor; both had painted en plein air for many years longer than I had. Both are respected in the Midwest, and have made work - plein air and studio - that are still beyond my own personal limits. 

But the similarities between the two end there, as their careers have gone in very different directions lately.  The sadness I have for my elder friend's predicament is paired with joy I have looking at my other friend's success. And yet, that strange dichotomy forces me to sit back and deeply contemplate the savage unpredictability of the art world.


I wish I could firmly believe that hard work and a constant drive for mastery and innovation would lead to stability and greater freedom for all artists, but that's never been true. I didn't get into painting with the assumption that all efforts would be reliably rewarded, but the constant reminder of the uncontrollable winds which guide the ships we sail is nevertheless unsettling. Sometimes those winds blow in our favor, and sometimes they don't. Sometimes all artists feel as though the ship they sail has begun to drift aimlessly at sea. 

 

"Cascade" - 36x36" - 2007 - Oil on canvas

 

I return to this analogy of water time and time again as I try to explain to others what it feels like to constantly subject oneself to judgement and critique,  and to face omnipresent uncertainty about the future. Personally, I often feel as though the day to day oscillation of acceptance and rejection feels like being deep under choppy seas, unable to breathe. Every minute there's a flip of a coin: heads and I'm above water, breathing and staring at the sun above, perhaps with a glimpse of a distant shore; tails and I'm still submerged, unable to breathe. So far I've been lucky enough to not have a run of bad luck that leaves me truly drowning, but I've seen others who have and it tears me up inside to witness it. When the soul and dreams of an artist suffer a mortal blow, there's no recovery.

We as artists are all familiar with this experience. And yet, one thing I've noticed within the plein air scene is that it's frowned upon to discuss it. A few weeks ago I was rejected from a desert painting event for the third year in a row, and my public notes of sadness were met with a range of reactions including, but not limited to, 'just shut up and paint.'

 

"Self Portait With Beard" - 2008 - Oil on canvas

 

In a world where brightly burning figures like Van Gogh are in the vanguard of modern art, it's inexcusable to not discuss the emotional experience of being an artist - both the delightful and tragic elements. In the last few years I've watched my two closest artist friends die unexpectedly, alone and in poverty, their dreams unfulfilled. I've lost romantic partners in no small part due to the uncertainty of my own career, while watching my high school and college friends get married, buy homes, and have children. I've painted for fifteen years, and five of those have been spent painting en plein air - and I'm still very far from the shore where I might find any of that.

And yet, to express more than constant joy and gratification for our perpetually Instagramable life as an outdoor painter is a huge faux pas. I grew up in the large Midwestern cities of St. Paul and Minneapolis, surrounded by a dark and gritty side of the art world where poverty, alcoholism, depression, insomnia, and art were invariably intertwined. Art was about loss and heart break; expressions of existential pain and shattered dreams were the unifying energy in the back alleys of Uptown or the warehouse parties of Northeast. In that world, which I found myself part of immediately after college, everybody needed therapy and nobody could afford it. And yet today I somehow find myself a highly active participant in a market that expects both art and artists to be generally pleasant in their presentation.

 

"David and Goliath" - 20x24 - 2010 - Acrylic on canvas

 

I'm comfortable bucking that societal expectation, if only out of respect for those who have lost more than me and feel uncomfortable being open with their story. The media surrounding the plein air world doesn't often discuss anything but the dream of capturing beauty and finding a sense of purpose within that artistic endeavor. Most people want to bask in the warmth of that dream while ignoring the pain that, in my case and that of others, may serve as its foundation.

 

"Trinity" - 36x24" - 2010 - Acrylic on canvas

There are 'well behaved' painters in the plein air world, who play by the rules and adopt a public image of adventure, mastery, and success. I'd like to be one, but that's not the hand I was dealt. I'd rather serve as a reminder that it's ok to be at home in darkness and paint to escape it. I know I'm not the only one, and I want others to know they're not alone if they can relate. The community of artists in this world is shaped like an iceberg: A only a select few ever get to see above the waves.

I'll finish with some appropriately dark lyrics that should finally bring meaning to the post title, and my most recent self-portrait ... which is now 7 years old, so I guess it's time to upgrade.

 

"The world is a vampire sent to drain

Secret destroyers hold you up to the flames

And what do I get for my pain?

Betrayed desires and a piece of the game"

 


"Narcissus" - 40x30" - 2012 - Oil and acrylic on canvas

 

- Philip


Comments

9 Responses to A Bullet with Butterfly Wings

Philip,
I love your work, as you know.

For what ever reason, people struggle to think individually. Art galleries will be soon gone, like Sears.
Like Frank Lloyd Wright, the dialogue (language) for people to understand forces them to think a lot deeper than most people are willing to think.

They rather buy a stainless steel bunny from Sotheby's, which $$$ would put a dent in the cleaning up of the floating plastic in our oceans.
I want you to know that I admire your ability to live simple and paint real.
I am on your side.

All that you said is right. And so are the folks who say, "Just paint." Can you not see how these complement each other?

Bob - Yes, I totally agree with that. But there's a massive difference between saying "Just paint" and "Shut up and paint".

11 years ago a close friend left me a voicemail that said "No matter what happens, keep painting!". I still haven't deleted it, nor have I stopped painting.

I'm not going to quit painting, nor do I think anybody ever should. But we can can keep creating while also sharing with the world the day to day ups and downs of the endeavor! 

Philip, that you are reaching out to a community that reads your blog and is familiar with your work is such a validation of of a human need for a "community". It's a profound aspect of life that provides genuine purpose to our daily work. I look forward to reading more from you, as well as continuing to see your work posted on Facebook. Thanks for this. It is starting my own day in the studio.

Thought of you today before reading about the Met's exhibit of David Caspar Friedrich then clicked to this post because of the lyrics referenced. Thank you for being you. The grotesque and the beautiful are co-dependent; in reflecting their depths and heights through paint passages you're (still) gifting shorelines to the sublime. Kudos from an Uptown apartment with mountain hiking/biking--air--envy. Still bouldering. : -)

Thought of you today before reading about the Met's exhibit of David Caspar Friedrich then clicked to this post because of the lyrics referenced. Thank you for being you. The grotesque and the beautiful are co-dependent; in reflecting their depths and heights through paint passages you're (still) gifting shorelines to the sublime. Kudos from an Uptown apartment with mountain hiking/biking--air--envy. Still bouldering. : -)

Thought of you today before reading about the Met's exhibit of David Caspar Friedrich then clicked to this post because of the lyrics referenced. Thank you for being you. The grotesque and the beautiful are co-dependent; in reflecting their depths and heights through paint passages you're (still) gifting shorelines to the sublime. Kudos from an Uptown apartment with mountain hiking/biking--air--envy. Still bouldering. : -)

Write another comment . . .

Write another comment . . .


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post